Rock Mechanics and Rock Engineering

It is super slow. It took 2 months without being sent for external review. 6-22 submitted to journal; 7-22 editor invited; 8-18 reject. Due to the large number of manuscripts the Journal receives and the requisite high rejection rate (about 90%), all decisions regarding publications are final.

(80) Thank | 无始无终

Super slow. The cycle of the first review depends on luck. Numerical/ experimental/ field issues are involved. After all, it is a comprehensive journal. The self-citation rate is too high and the article is not as good as people said. The article is of average value. For example, as I major in numerical calculations, I will definitely not search for articles from RMRE because it is not professional. In addition, there are some articles published due to personal favors.

(21) Thank | IamAReader

The editor is an internationally renowned academic bigwig in the United States.  It took 2 months for the first review and the feedback was that the paper showed insufficient innovation, but they recommended I resubmit. If you have really innovative discoveries, you can submit, but if no real breakthroughs, better not try. The review cycle from submission to acceptance is relatively long. 10 months is normal, half a year if you’re lucky, a year and a half if you’re not. It is well-recognized in the field of rock mechanics and engineering, it has very strict formatting requirements, and its requirements are very high.

(6) Thank | 打不死的小强

2018.01.25 contribution, after two overhauls, 2018.08.12 is accepted, the review proposal is very valuable.

(0) Thank | zgbhpu@163.com

Bull journal, but now it seems that the review is a lot slower, the manuscript is too much estimated

(0) Thank | coal

submitted the overhaul opinion two months later, and submitted it after one month of revision. Currently in the external trial, hope is a good result.The overall review speed is very fast.

(0) Thank | LUKY

selectd for about a week to receive the manuscript, and then about half a month for the external review, now the foreign trial for a month, the expectation will be a good result

(0) Thank | 1009159198@qq.com

Submitted in late April of 2017, overhauled in July, revised directly in mid-September, still relatively smooth

(7) Thank | xxh写论文

7 At the beginning of the month, more than 4 months before returning to the review comments, after a meal, and under review, continue to wait for a long time.At the time of the select, I read the comments very quickly. Is there more manuscript in the second half of the year?

(0) Thank | kly582@163.com

the top journal of rock mechanics, the review is slowHigh expectations.

(0) Thank | no

submitted on January 20th, 2017, rejected, English is not up to standard;Re-submitment on February 12, overhaul on May 18;Revised on August 8th, submitted for review on the 12th, and overhauled on October 20th;Revised on November 1st and accepted on the 16th.I feel that the reviewers' comments are very good, and they have finally paid off in nine months.

(8) Thank | wangchxizo@163.com

is mainly biased towards a complete experiment or formula derivation.The editor is more responsible, not the related household journals upstairs.

(17) Thank | 没有昵称

, the editor-in-chief of Italy, I really took it.The first shot said the article, it is recommended to modify it into a technical note and then select.After a month of revision, re-submitment, into the external audit, the external audit of two experts a minor repair, a major repair.But the editor gave it a refusal.The same category of articles, submitted international rock mechanics is modified to accept.Now I really doubt that this journal is a legendary relationship journal.Only articles from domestic relations households.If you are not particularly familiar with this journal, I suggest you not waste time.There are also N pieces of rock mechanics related paper, which are directly rejected.Reason out of scopeThis Giovanni Barla of the Polytechnic.I took him.Never select for this garbage anymore.

(42) Thank | Father of Giovanni Barla

好难

(1) Thank | 啊飒飒

Returns comments in one month, and two months after overhaul.

(1) Thank | chengguanwen@126.com

@Wangzhiliang@163.comThe RMRE journal now has a high impact factor and is a large cattle journal in the geotechnical community.As for what you said is worse than the International Journal of Rock Mechanics and Mining Sciences, it may not be obvious. It is because of the quick review, so many new results have been released. Some details are also normal and cannot be perfect. The same mistake is in the International Journal of Rock.It can also be found in Mechanics and Mining Sciences.

(1) Thank | yanwu1206

An authoritative publication in the field of rock mechanics and engineering. The publication is quicker to review, and the editor is receiving the advice of the first reviewer.Then, it will proceed, and then decide whether to make the revision or directly reject the draft. If it is revised, it will be sent to the second reviewer after the revision. Based on the opinion of the second reviewer, it is finally decided whether the article will be published.Compared with the International Journal of Rock Mechanics and Mining Sciences, this journal is much faster to review, but the level of the paper is still a bit worse than the International Journal of Rock and Mining Science.

(3) Thank | Wangzhiliang@163.com

has undergone major repairs to minor repairs and finally acceptd.Before the overhaul, a reviewer gave a sharp speech and directly rejected the manuscript. After two months of careful study, he added a lot of novel points, adjusted the format of the article, and finally convinced the reviewer and editor.But I really appreciate their unselfish and serious work.

(1) Thank | yanwu1206

Edited to reject the manuscript, reply as follows.However, I submitted it as required. Except for the fourth article, I did not find an organization to polish.May I ask who submitted the manuscript is successful, can you give me guidance?Focus on the meaning of the second article.Thank you.Typically note:1. references in the text and in the list of references should be according to the guidelines.2. Figures and tables should follow the text.3. Add a list of symbols following the keywords.4. Have the manuscript edited for English by using and English editing service.

(1) Thank | ss

I would like to ask everyone, may I ask ROCK MECHANICS AND ROCK ENGINEERING this journal, is there a fee?My qq122235791

(1) Thank | sunqin1998

The review speed is very fast, and the comments are very pertinent. The impact factor is rising quickly and worthy of a select.

(1) Thank | Anonymous

The review speed is very fast, the reviewers are invited to the international rock mechanics big cattle level figures, the opinions given are more pertinent, and the publication speed of the journals is also very fast.

(1) Thank | yanwu

The review speed is very fast, and the reviewer's opinion is received in one and a half months, and accepted one month later.IJRMMS is really too slow. There has been an article for more than half a year, and it is still with editor.

(0) Thank | Anonymous

The article on engineering geology should not be submitted here because they are mainly biased towards a complete experiment or formula derivation involving applications.It's hard to be recognized, of course it's not that it's not possible to accept. It's just that it's hard.

(1) Thank | Anonymous

level is OK, but it is all the big man review manuscript

(0) Thank | Anonymous