JOURNAL OF MATERIALS ENGINEERING AND PERFORMANCE

I despaired of this journal, even wordless. I submitted the manuscript last August. I received the notifications of rejection and resubmission in November. Then I revised and resubmitted. It took another seven months to receive the notification in June this year. During the process I once urged. I could not believe that it was a decision of rejection and resubmission again, with four comments. I resubmitted the article again in June and there was still no news for more than three months. I couldn't agree with the editor of the journal, indeed. I don’t want to say anything about these reviewers. Were the four comments the reason why they replied after a few months? What’s worse, some of the questions they asked were even wrong. Were they a bunch of amateurs who reviewed my article?

(3) Thank | 海清粉

09-Jan-2019, 06-Feb-2019, 30-Oct-2018, 31-Dec-2018, 29-Aug-2018, 29-Sep-2018, 02-May-2018, 04-Aug-2018. I said at the time that if it can be accepted, I will share it right away, it lasted eight months. All other articles have been accepted. My heart hurt for the submission. I submitted the manuscript in April 2018, and it was accepted in February 2019, I revised again and again during that period. The reviewer’s comments were very pertinent, and I revised again and again. It only took a week to be published. I wish you all the articles can be accepted. Finally, I wish me a smooth graduation!

(2) Thank | 林冬添

I thought that the reviewers’ opinions were not uniform. I received a minor revision decision which asked me to adjust the size of the image and the position of the ruler and delete the chemical composition in the image and describe it in words.

(1) Thank | 呆虫

The speed is too slow, submitted for more than three months, still under review, hey, it’s really anxious.

(0) Thank | 海清粉

Submitted in January 18, first month for 3 months, modified one month later, one second trialMonth, after minor repairs agreed to receive no further review.After the result of the upload, the editor has submitted the review, and there is no news until October. The article is changed to wait for the assistant editorial comments.It hasn't changed in the past two months. After the second draft, there was no reply, just in time for Christmas.Received news in the second half of New Year's Day.For nearly a year, I feel that the efficiency of assistant editors and reviewers needs to be improved.

(4) Thank | 游走在学术边缘的人

A full 5 months, the results of the first trial.Minor repair, no problem, let the grammar be modified, hahaha.

(0) Thank | 潇洒哥

5 months, I want to retract.There is no news in the first instance, I have been under review, your sister.

(8) Thank | 潇洒哥

has been submitteding for 3 months, no news

(3) Thank | 422916711@qq.com

There is also no email inquiry, and there is no message after replying to the receipt email.

(2) Thank | chenpinghu1986@163.com

is really speechless, 10 months still have no results, too slow and too slow, will not choose this journal again.

(0) Thank | qq

and one irresponsible journal, sent me an email after more than ten days, saying that my article has been accepted, but after a week, I gave it again.I sent an e-mail saying that the e-mail sent to me was a mis-delivery. It is really a irresponsible journal. It is recommended not to select. The review period is long.

(0) Thank | 111111

Uploaded on November 17, 2017, received directly on December 2, 2017, no modification!!!This comment will take months to give the news, I did not expect to receive it directly in 15 days.

(3) Thank | Anonymous

Breaking the journal, too slow, the first major repair, the second minor repair, the third major overhaul, the fourth time to polish, I will go, can not solve it at once?#

(1) Thank | hello world！

5.28Submission,7.15 returned to speak English too bad, looking for a touch-up mechanism to polish,7.31 Rework.8.20 The second opinion returned,8.27 Rework.9.26 acceptThe reviewers still put forward some useful comments.

(0) Thank | 614995914@qq.com

has gone through two years from submission to publication. The first time I requested minor repairs. After the revision, I waited for half a year and asked for major changes. After the revision, it was half a year, and then it was half a year and half a year.

(3) Thank | M.

Review speed is still quite fast, two reviewers.The first reviewer gave 15 comments, but they were all questions, and there were not many suggestions for specific revisions; the second reviewer’s five comments were minor.The editor may have more questions. The advice is: Suggestions are published, but major revisions are required.I dragged myself for nearly two months, and today I returned to the revised draft, and then the status immediately became under review, I hope good luck!

(0) Thank | 1031683160@qq.com

has been engaged for 4 months, and stayed in the assistant editor for one month.I have been in the editor for a week now. I don’t understand what is going on?Is it so entangled in a message?

(0) Thank | 恋上你的不经意

Although the review time is long, but the editor is responsible, the reviewer's opinion is pertinent, it is estimated that this year IF should be greatly increased

(1) Thank | ll

editor super responsible, overhaul twice, the article quality has leapThanks for his advice.Already the second one, I will select again.

(1) Thank | 小小红

The editor is very responsible, will take every manuscript seriously, will not casually refuse to accept the manuscript, the reviewer's advice is also very pertinent, to improve the author's writing level and scientific research attitude is veryhelp.

(0) Thank | pexyunda@163.com

Journal manuscript processing speed is relatively slow, but the review comments are very pertinent, and the overall improvement of the article is very helpful.Journal articles have higher language requirements, and they are not very serious in writing themselves. They have been repeatedly changed twice.Although I experienced a long wait and three major overhauls, I finally received it, if not high (the characteristics of SPRINGER), but it is also the result of my own efforts.

(0) Thank | duibuqi88888@163.com

This article is very slow, the article has lasted for 8 months, no results.In the hands of the deputy editor, the state can last for one month, and will not select again in the future, away from such journals.

(17) Thank | hucym

The journal is still not as slow as it was said, from submission to recruitment for 4.5 months, during the period of overhaul to minor repairs, and finally to language problems.The editor is still very responsible, give EO: Whitelaw, Diane like one.

(5) Thank | shdxlishuang@126.com

The speed is still very fast. It takes three and a half months from submission to receiving. The first time to send back the review comments is two months, overhaul, return after half a month, the result is halfAfter the month, I will send back the overhaul opinion again.After rearranging the language, I will select again and receive it directly in one week.Editing is very good, great praise

(7) Thank | dmjmep

8Submission at the end of the month November 9th Review Review Opinion Overhaul

(3) Thank | Anonymous